All Star Pizza - The Best Pizza in Rhode Island

During this MLB All Star break, it only seemed appropriate for my husband and I to pick up dinner from our favorite local pizza shop, All Star Pizza.

All Star Pizza, 417 Broad Street, Cumberland, RI 02864

Located in Cumberland, Rhode Island All Star Pizza is owned by brothers Brian and Steve Seagrave.

From the name, to the colors painted outside the building it is apparent baseball is going to be a theme in this pizza shop - but just wait until you step inside.

Once opened, the door chimes with "Take Me Out To The Ballgame" and everywhere you look are pieces of Red Sox memorabilia. There are bats, World Series pictures, pennants, a mini scoreboard/green monster, Red Sox pizza cutters, cotton candy and even a the light switches are Red Sox themed!

Red Sox Memorabilia in All Star Pizza

As much as it's fun to look around while picking up your order (or dining in at one of the high top tables located within the small shop), All Star really hits a homerun with its food.

They have some signature items like friend pickles and wieners served Rhode Island style (yellow mustard, diced onions, seasoned meat sauce and celery salt) and seriously some of the best pizza I've ever had. Their pizza dough and sauce are made from scratch and they smother their toppings in cheese.

Look at that cheese-covered pepperoni goodness!

I even hear in the fall they serve a special Thanksgiving Pizza (brown gravy, chunks of turkey, bread stuffing, green beans and mozzarella cheese). Yes, please!

In addition to the wonderful atmosphere and outstanding food All Star also offers free delivery and the best prices around.

If I had one (or two) small wishes it would have been 1) That All Star supported their local professional baseball team, the Pawtucket Red Sox a little bit within their shop and 2) Sports was on their TV instead of Cake Boss ;)

But seriously if you're ever in the area or looking to try some great pizza check out All Star Pizza. Tell 'em SoxyLady sent you.

All Star Pizza

417 Broad Street

Cumberland, RI 02864

401-725-SLAM

Business Hours:
Sun-Thurs: 11 AM - 11 PM

Fri - Sat: 11 AM - 1 AM

Like All Star Pizza on Facebook

View pictures of All Star Pizza's Menu on Facebook

No free pizza or other offers were exchanged for this review. In fact, nobody at All Star even knows who I am. I just want to support this local Rhode Island business and fellow Sox fans! 

Follow @SoxyLady